Skip to content

DA8. The Halting Problem

Statement

  • Describe in your own words what the halting problems is?
  • Why it is relevant to the design and analysis of algorithms?
  • Include one or two examples to explain your thought process to show what is occurring and how the methodology works.
  • Demonstrate your understanding of the intricacies of the halting problem and its influence on algorithms.
  • Use APA citations and references for any sources used.

Answer

Introduction

Algorithms are a finite set of instructions that can be followed to solve a problem. Impossible problems are problems that cannot be solved by any algorithm; that is, its solution cannot be computed in a finite number of steps. Examples include the halting problem and the decision problem, or any problem that may involve an infinite loop in its solution (UoPeople, 2025).

The Halting Problem

“The Halting Problem asks whether a given program or algorithm will eventually halt (terminate) or continue running indefinitely for a particular input” (GeeksforGeeks, 2018). In other words, it tries to determine if a program will face an infinite loop when processing a specific input.

The halting problem is impossible because there is no program that positively determines that a program will halt for an arbitrary input or even for a specific input. This is undecidable problem as we can not theoretically determine program’s behavior before running it on all possible inputs.

Why is it relevant to the design and analysis of algorithms?

The halting problem is relevant to the design and analysis of algorithms because it highlights the limitations of computation and the inherent complexity of certain problems. It was the driver behind Alan Turing’s work on computability theory, which laid the foundation for modern computer science (Mlo, 2019).

It is important for programmers to be able to recognize an NP-complete or impossible problem so that they don’t unknowingly waste time trying to solve a problem that is unsolvable or unpractical to solve. Understanding the halting problem helps programmers and computer scientists recognize when a problem may not have a solution or when an algorithm may not terminate.

Examples of the Halting Problem

The Collatz sequence is a well-known example of the halting problem. The sequence takes a positive integer n and divides it by 2 if it is even, or multiplies it by 3 and adds 1 if it is odd. The sequence continues until it reaches 1 or below, according to the following code (Shaffer, 2011):

while (n > 1) {
    if (isOdd(n)) n = 3 * n + 1;
    else n = n / 2;
}

The problem with the Collatz sequence is that it is NOT known whether all positive integers will eventually reach 1 and hence halt or go for ever (infinite loop). For example, the number 27 takes 111 steps to reach 1, while the number 4 takes only 2 steps. The sequence is not guaranteed to halt (reach 1) for all positive integers, making it an example of impossible halting problem.

Another example is the Busy Beaver problem, which is a theoretical problem that asks for the maximum number of steps a Turing machine with a given number of states can take before halting when started on an empty tape. The usual Turing machine has an infinite tape and a finite set of states; when limiting the number of states, the question becomes if the machine will halt before running out of states or if it will run until the last state without the program ever finishing (WikiPedia, 2002).

References

‌